William Cope
Pinakini Shah
Nadia Ayub
Miquel Colobran.png "Samuel Chukwuemeka Obasi")
Samuel Chukwuemeka Obasi
Sara RichterLearning, Knowledge and Human Development MOOC’s Updates
6. Productive Struggle in Learning (George Reese)
Comment: Educational psychology is also concerned with the dynamics of learning. In his contribution to this course, George Reese analyzes by way of example the notion of "productive struggle." How can educational psychology help us to understand the processes of learning?
Make an Update: Take one area of the learning sciences. How does educational psychology contribute to our understanding? What evidence does it offer? What interpretative concepts and theories does it provide?
Komentar: Psikologi Pendidikan dan Dinamika “Perjuangan Produktif”
Gagasan productive struggle atau “perjuangan produktif” adalah salah satu konsep penting dalam psikologi pendidikan yang menekankan pentingnya ketekunan dan usaha kognitif dalam pembelajaran. Alih-alih melihat kesulitan sebagai tanda kegagalan, psikologi pendidikan membantu kita memahami bahwa struggle dalam konteks belajar justru merupakan bagian penting dari proses internalisasi pengetahuan. George Reese menunjukkan bagaimana siswa bisa belajar lebih dalam ketika mereka diberi kesempatan untuk bergulat dengan masalah yang menantang—dengan bimbingan yang cukup, tetapi tidak langsung diberi jawabannya.
Komentar: Psikologi Pendidikan dan Dinamika “Perjuangan Produktif”
Gagasan productive struggle atau “perjuangan produktif” adalah salah satu konsep penting dalam psikologi pendidikan yang menekankan pentingnya ketekunan dan usaha kognitif dalam pembelajaran. Alih-alih melihat kesulitan sebagai tanda kegagalan, psikologi pendidikan membantu kita memahami bahwa struggle dalam konteks belajar justru merupakan bagian penting dari proses internalisasi pengetahuan. George Reese menunjukkan bagaimana siswa bisa belajar lebih dalam ketika mereka diberi kesempatan untuk bergulat dengan masalah yang menantang—dengan bimbingan yang cukup, tetapi tidak langsung diberi jawabannya.
The Educational Psychology's Point of View Regarding Productive Struggle
Comment:
Educational psychology examines how learning happens and how frustration and difficulty lead to better understanding and comprehension. George Reese illustrates the importance of productive struggle by highlighting how the difficulty leads to more advanced cognitive development if only it is supported correctly. Educational psychology addresses this by referring to motivation, cognitive load, and scaffolding techniques through which learners can manage frustration without giving up the activity. Teachers can design lessons that promote resilience and critical thinking through understanding of how children learn and can cope with adversity, ultimately resulting in a better learning experience.
Update:
One of the primary areas in the learning sciences is metacognition or reflecting on and regulating one's own learning process. Educational psychology advances the state of metacognition by providing research on self-regulated learning, goal setting, and reflective strategies that enhance student achievement. The research determined that students who check continuously for their comprehension, change their approach, and seek help when in need perform better in class. Two theories that describe how students tackle difficult tasks and develop their future capacity for independent work on problems are Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development and Flavell's Theory of Metacognition.
The Educational Psychology's Point of View Regarding Productive Struggle
Comment:
Educational psychology examines how learning happens and how frustration and difficulty lead to better understanding and comprehension. George Reese illustrates the importance of productive struggle by highlighting how the difficulty leads to more advanced cognitive development if only it is supported correctly. Educational psychology addresses this by referring to motivation, cognitive load, and scaffolding techniques through which learners can manage frustration without giving up the activity. Teachers can design lessons that promote resilience and critical thinking through understanding of how children learn and can cope with adversity, ultimately resulting in a better learning experience.
Update:
One of the primary areas in the learning sciences is metacognition or reflecting on and regulating one's own learning process. Educational psychology advances the state of metacognition by providing research on self-regulated learning, goal setting, and reflective strategies that enhance student achievement. The research determined that students who check continuously for their comprehension, change their approach, and seek help when in need perform better in class. Two theories that describe how students tackle difficult tasks and develop their future capacity for independent work on problems are Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development and Flavell's Theory of Metacognition.
Educational psychology helps us understand how people learn by examining how learners engage with challenges and construct knowledge. One key idea is productive struggle, which suggests that learners grow and learn best when they are faced with tasks that require effort and persistence. This aligns with **constructivism**, a theory that emphasizes learners actively building their own understanding based on prior knowledge and experiences. Educational psychology shows that learning is not just about receiving information but actively solving problems and engaging with new ideas.
Research supports this idea. For example, studies on problem-solving have shown that when learners face challenges, they not only develop their cognitive abilities but also build perseverance. Carol Dweck’s **growth mindset** theory aligns with this by showing that students who believe their abilities can grow with effort are more likely to persist through difficulties, leading to deeper learning. Vygotsky’s **Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD)** also supports the concept of productive struggle, suggesting that learners benefit from tasks slightly beyond their current abilities but achievable with support. This balance between challenge and support helps learners progress.
Another concept from educational psychology is **scaffolding**, where teachers or peers provide temporary help to learners until they can complete tasks independently. This kind of support encourages productive struggle by allowing students to tackle difficult tasks while gradually becoming more capable on their own.
In summary, educational psychology provides valuable insights into how learners grow and develop. Concepts like constructivism, productive struggle, growth mindset, and scaffolding show that learners thrive when they are challenged but supported. These ideas help educators create environments that foster deeper learning and resilience.
Educational psychology enriches our understanding of the learning process by offering evidence-based practices, theories, and frameworks that highlight how cognitive, emotional, and social factors contribute to learning. Through concepts like productive struggle, the Zone of Proximal Development, and constructivism, educational psychology helps us develop more effective teaching strategies that foster deeper engagement, independent problem-solving, and overall academic success. By applying these principles, educators can better support students in overcoming challenges, leading to a more meaningful and enduring learning experience.
Educational psychology enriches our understanding of the learning process by offering evidence-based practices, theories, and frameworks that highlight how cognitive, emotional, and social factors contribute to learning. Through concepts like productive struggle, the Zone of Proximal Development, and constructivism, educational psychology helps us develop more effective teaching strategies that foster deeper engagement, independent problem-solving, and overall academic success. By applying these principles, educators can better support students in overcoming challenges, leading to a more meaningful and enduring learning experience.
Educational psychology enriches our understanding of the learning process by offering evidence-based practices, theories, and frameworks that highlight how cognitive, emotional, and social factors contribute to learning. Through concepts like productive struggle, the Zone of Proximal Development, and constructivism, educational psychology helps us develop more effective teaching strategies that foster deeper engagement, independent problem-solving, and overall academic success. By applying these principles, educators can better support students in overcoming challenges, leading to a more meaningful and enduring learning experience.
A common debate that often arises in the realm of education is whether certain subjects are truly necessary unless they align with a specific career path. Many people tend to dismiss subjects like math, for example, as only useful for careers that involve direct application of numbers. However, education and psychology both emphasize that learning is about much more than just acquiring facts—it's about developing essential life skills that will serve individuals in a variety of contexts. As George Reese explains through the concept of productive struggle, the value of education lies not in simply memorizing information, but in how we engage with challenges, develop perseverance, and learn to think critically.
Education is much more than the transfer of knowledge; it is a tool for shaping how we think. Psychology plays a crucial role in this process by offering insights into how our brains learn and adapt. When we study complex subjects, we are not just learning specific content, but we are also learning how to think critically, how to solve problems, and how to approach difficult situations with resilience. These skills are not limited to any one field—they are universally valuable and apply to all areas of life. Whether you are tackling a professional challenge, making a personal decision, or navigating everyday problems, the ability to think analytically and critically is invaluable. This is precisely why education is about fostering these deeper cognitive skills, not just delivering facts.
As George Reese highlights, “productive struggle” is a crucial aspect of the learning process. It’s the idea that when we face challenges, our brains engage more deeply, and we develop important skills like persistence, problem-solving, and adaptability. Psychological research supports this, showing that overcoming obstacles, rather than avoiding them, is what leads to true learning. The struggle is not a sign of failure, but a sign that the brain is working and developing. The resilience built through confronting difficult material is a foundational element of personal growth.
Moreover, education teaches us to be adaptable in our thinking. Sometimes, the first approach we take to solve a problem doesn’t work, and this is where flexibility comes into play. Learning is about trying different methods, evaluating outcomes, and adjusting strategies. This ability to pivot and reframe challenges is essential in today's fast-paced world, where change is constant. Psychology tells us that this flexibility in thinking strengthens our ability to respond effectively to a variety of situations, whether in the workplace, in relationships, or in daily life.
Another key lesson from education is the development of persistence. It’s easy to give up when faced with difficulty, but education encourages us to stick with challenges, to learn from failures, and to push forward. Psychological theories on growth mindset emphasize the importance of perseverance, showing that those who continue to tackle obstacles are more likely to achieve success. The persistence that education fosters is not just about academic achievement—it’s about building the mental strength to face adversity in all aspects of life.
In conclusion, education, supported by the principles of psychology, offers far more than just specific knowledge in any given subject. It provides the tools to think critically, problem-solve, and build resilience. The skills we develop through the learning process—whether in math, language, or any other field—are transferable to every aspect of life. As George Reese emphasizes, “productive struggle” is essential for growth and learning. So, the next time we consider the value of education, we must remember that it’s not just about mastering content—it’s about developing the critical thinking, persistence, and flexibility that prepare us for success in any endeavor. @Samaa Haniya,
### Educational Psychology and the Dynamics of Learning
Educational psychology plays a crucial role in understanding the **dynamics of learning** by examining how students acquire knowledge, develop skills, and engage with educational content. One of the key concepts discussed in the field is **productive struggle**. This term, as explored by **George Reese**, refers to the learning process in which students face challenges and difficulties that push them to think critically and problem-solve, yet are supported in such a way that they do not become discouraged or overwhelmed. Productive struggle is seen as essential for deep learning because it encourages persistence and engagement with complex tasks.
Educational psychology helps us understand these dynamics by providing theories and frameworks that explain how cognitive, emotional, and social factors influence learning. Through the lens of educational psychology, we can examine how various strategies, such as providing the right balance of challenge and support, can promote growth and resilience in learners.
### Understanding Productive Struggle through Educational Psychology
The concept of **productive struggle** fits within broader theories of **constructivism**, which suggests that learning is most effective when students are active participants in the learning process, engaging with materials and ideas in a way that encourages critical thinking and problem-solving. Educational psychology, through this lens, helps identify what conditions make struggle productive, such as the right balance of difficulty, prior knowledge, and social support.
The evidence behind productive struggle suggests that students who experience appropriate levels of challenge and are guided through this struggle can achieve greater conceptual understanding and retain knowledge longer. This concept is closely related to the idea of **zone of proximal development (ZPD)**, proposed by **Lev Vygotsky**, where learners work just beyond their current capabilities but within reach, with the help of scaffolding or guidance.
### How Educational Psychology Contributes to the Learning Sciences
One area of the learning sciences where educational psychology makes a significant contribution is in **cognitive load theory**. Cognitive load refers to the mental effort required to process information during learning, and understanding how to manage this load is essential for effective instruction. Educational psychology provides valuable insights into how instructional design can optimize cognitive load to support learning.
#### What Evidence Does Educational Psychology Offer?
Research in educational psychology supports the idea that instructional methods should be designed with the learner's cognitive load in mind. Studies show that when learning tasks are too complex or presented in a way that overwhelms the learner's working memory, learning can be hindered. Conversely, when instructional strategies align with the learner's cognitive capacity, the likelihood of successful learning increases.
One key finding is the **split-attention effect**, where learners struggle when they have to process multiple sources of information simultaneously (e.g., reading text while watching a video). Educational psychology suggests that breaking down information into manageable chunks, presenting content in a coherent sequence, and offering multimedia support can help manage cognitive load and facilitate deeper learning.
#### Interpretative Concepts and Theories
Educational psychology provides several key interpretative concepts and theories to understand the learning process more deeply:
1. **Cognitive Load Theory**: This theory suggests that learners have a limited capacity for processing information. Educational psychology uses this framework to understand how to manage instructional materials and tasks to avoid overwhelming students' cognitive resources. Evidence suggests that instructional designs that reduce extraneous cognitive load (e.g., through clear instructions, visual aids, and chunking information) lead to better learning outcomes.
2. **Constructivism**: As mentioned, this theory emphasizes active, hands-on learning where students engage with content through problem-solving and exploration. Educational psychology helps us understand how students construct knowledge by interacting with their environment, their peers, and their instructors. For example, in a classroom setting, the teacher's role is to provide scaffolding that helps the learner navigate through their productive struggle while avoiding frustration.
3. **Motivation Theories**: Theories like **Self-Determination Theory (SDT)** and **Goal Orientation Theory** from educational psychology provide insight into how motivation impacts learning. For example, SDT emphasizes the importance of autonomy, competence, and relatedness for fostering intrinsic motivation. Understanding these motivational factors is key to creating environments where learners are willing to engage in productive struggle, as they are more likely to persist through challenges when they feel competent and supported.
4. **Metacognition**: This concept refers to learners' awareness of their own learning processes. Educational psychology helps us understand how teaching strategies can promote metacognitive skills, such as self-regulation, goal-setting, and reflective thinking. Students who are trained to monitor and adjust their learning strategies are better equipped to engage in productive struggle and develop independent learning skills.
### Conclusion
In summary, **educational psychology** provides valuable insights into the dynamics of learning, helping us understand how students process information, face challenges, and build knowledge. Through concepts like **cognitive load**, **constructivism**, and **motivational theories**, educational psychology informs our understanding of what makes learning effective, especially when learners encounter challenges. The evidence from educational psychology suggests that providing the right balance of difficulty, offering scaffolding, and supporting students' emotional and cognitive needs are crucial for facilitating **productive struggle**, which ultimately leads to deeper and more lasting learning. By applying these insights, educators can design more effective learning environments that encourage persistence, critical thinking, and resilience.
@Bhavesh Parihar,
A common debate that often arises in the realm of education is whether certain subjects are truly necessary unless they align with a specific career path. Many people tend to dismiss subjects like math, for example, as only useful for careers that involve direct application of numbers. However, education and psychology both emphasize that learning is about much more than just acquiring facts—it's about developing essential life skills that will serve individuals in a variety of contexts. As George Reese explains through the concept of productive struggle, the value of education lies not in simply memorizing information, but in how we engage with challenges, develop perseverance, and learn to think critically.